Belmar Bakery

Brandice Gober a month ago

The goodies were amazing but honestly the store is filthy. There was dirt and grime and dead bugs all over the floor and the bathrooms look like they havent been cleaned well in weeks. While I thoroughly enjoyed their cookies and my children loved their treats the cleanliness makes me second guess buying from here. Thank you for getting back to this comment. The filth was more than 1 days worth. I appreciate you trying to lessen it but I know when something is cleaned daily and the amount of grime and dead bugs was too much.. the toilet and sink if scrubbed will wouldn't look like that. Behind the toilet was gross. You may need to revisit how its cleaned.

Julie Allen 2 months ago

I arrived shortly after the bakery opened at 7am. I ordered 6 cinnamon rolls and they were hot and fresh right out the oven so delicious. This was my first time here and I will definitely be coming back they also sale breads, jams, pies, cookies, and cake's. In so many different varieties.

Jessica Delgado 9 months ago

I have been a long time customer and have always ordered cakes and pies from Belmar. What happened to this place? I placed an order for my Thanksgiving pies over a week ago, went to pick them up the day before Thanksgiving at 4pm, I didn’t leave until around 7:30pm! There was a long line of ANGRY customers who were there long before I got there. I understand it’s a busy time but I never had this issue before. Every time a customer would ask how much longer until their orders were ready, they would say 5 mins, and each time, those 5 mins turned into hours. There were 5 employees, which included a manager, all except for one young girl with glasses were extremely rude to customers, including elderly customers!!! The girls were all standing around doing absolutely nothing while the place was a mess. A lot of customers didn’t even receive their pies and walked out. After 3 1/2 hours of waiting, I finally got my 2 pies. They looked HORRIBLE. I got a refund for one pie but in reality, I should have gotten a refund for both! I ordered 1 lemon meringue and 1 chocolate meringue pie, the pictures will speak for itself. I am sad to see how bad this place has gotten, not only the atmos

Paul Nolan Edited 4 months ago

It is update time. After my great disappointment in 2025 with the quality decline at Belmar Bakery, the owner took mine and others constructive criticism seriously. On the 24th of April 2026, I purchased 2 cherry pies, a cherry turnover and an iced Barvarian pretzel. My wife enoyed the pretzel, as I the flakey, light and sweet cherry filled turnover. The pies were for a family reunion the next day. A lot was riding on these pies for myself and Belmar Bakery. I personally visited with the manager/baker who made the pies that day. She personally assured me they were chock full of cherries. Looking at the pies I could see the cherries bulging through the flakey crust sprinkled with sugar crystals. On cutting and serving the pies, they truly were full of cherries, the cherry syrup was thick and held the plentiful cherries together and the pie did not drain flat when cut. The crust was firm but flakey and the sugar sprinkles added to the texture and flavor. Each bite of the pie was full of cherries from start to finish. The improvement was absolutely delightful and the fives stars I give now are well earned by the current manager/baker, WELL DONE, I say!!!

Alicyn Hill 2 years ago

My family has ordered cakes for the last 30 years, this year is the last. When I ordered the cake, everything was fine. When I went to pick it up, it wasn’t exactly what I had asked for so I asked for the correction. When cutting into the cake, the consistency was different and doughy. As soon as we bit into the cake you could tell that it was not fully baked. I return the cake and ended up speaking to the manager/owner who argued with me on the ingredients and the fact that she said it was fully cooked and was a vanilla cream cake and that is what it’s supposed to look like. I explained no that it made my family sick and we threw the pieces cut away. She finally gave a refund. Sadly this is the last special occasion will give Belmar business. Edit at 6:49am 08/06/24 I’m so glad the owner responded and tried to flip the conversation. She argued with me for a good 10 minutes on the ingredients and no way they can make you sick, until a gentleman pulled up to pick up his cake. I simply stated we got sick from eating what bites we took from this cake. At no point did I say anything about raw eggs or even eggs at all. She is the one who stated “this cake is not made with eggs, it is a